We may say most aptly that the Analytical Engine weaves algebraical patterns just as the Jacquard-loom weaves flowers and leaves.”
— Ada Lovelace, Notes on the Analytical Engine, 1843
BTC …

After Anna Ridler, Mosaic Virus (2018–19). The higher the price, the more the tulip breaks.

A tulip opens on a screen. It is red, then streaked with white, then almost red again. It never quite settles. Nobody planted it. A machine made it up, and the price of bitcoin decides how striped it gets.

The work is Mosaic Virus by Anna Ridler. The first version is from 2018. In the 2019 version there are three screens, each showing a single tulip.

Ten thousand tulips

Before the machine could make a tulip, Ridler had to show it what a tulip is. She took 10,000 photos of tulips and sorted them by hand. Then she stopped. In her words, the reason she "stopped making my dataset was because tulip season ended."

I like that. Under all the talk about artificial intelligence there is a person with a camera, a lot of flowers and a deadline set by spring. The photographs became a work of their own, Myriad (Tulips). Pinned to a wall one by one, they look like what they are. Labor.

A GAN learned from them and started producing tulips that never grew anywhere. When bitcoin goes up, the petals get more stripes. When it falls, they go back to a single color.

The stripes were a disease

In the 1630s the Dutch paid fortunes for tulips. The most wanted were the broken ones, with flames and feathers of color on the petals. Semper Augustus, white streaked with red, is believed to have been the most expensive of them all. The mania peaked between 1633 and 1637, and crashed early in 1637.

What nobody knew was that the stripes came from a virus, spread by aphids. It also weakens the bulb. So the most beautiful tulips were the sick ones, and the hardest to multiply, which is part of why they were rare. It took until the late 1920s, and Dorothy Cayley's experiments in England, before anyone understood it.

Semper Augustus no longer exists. In many countries it is now illegal to sell infected bulbs. The striped tulips you buy today are bred to look that way.

Ridler gives the virus a new host. "In the models that I created it is Bitcoin that behaves like the virus," she writes.

A townhouse and an onion

So the beauty was the symptom. People paying a fortune for a bulb were paying for an infection they couldn't see. Ridler's own phrase is that the tulip reached "the same price as an Amsterdam townhouse before falling to the price of an onion."

Now the stripes follow another kind of speculation, also invisible, also hard to understand for most of the people taking part. She has said she wanted to draw together "capitalism, value, and the tangible and intangible nature of speculation." She also said AI was "in its own bubble at the moment." That was in 2019.

What I keep coming back to is how little of it is real in the usual sense. The tulip was never grown, and the money moving its petals is a number in a ledger. And still it is beautiful to watch.

The flower on the screen opens. Somewhere a price moves, and the petals get a little more striped.

scroll

It is a strange shape for a painting. Thirty centimeters high and two meters long. A man lying on a white sheet in a stone box that is only just big enough for him. That is all there is.

Holbein's painting of the dead Christ lying full length on a white sheet in a narrow tomb
Hans Holbein the Younger, The Body of the Dead Christ in the Tomb, 1521–22. Kunstmuseum Basel.

Hans Holbein the Younger painted it in Basel in 1521 and 1522. He was in his mid-twenties. The painting has stayed in the city ever since, and today it hangs in the Kunstmuseum. For five hundred years people have stood in front of it and found it hard to leave. I have been trying to understand why.

Nothing else to look at

Most paintings of the dead Christ give you somewhere else to put your eyes. Mary, the disciples, an angel or two. Somebody who grieves, so you don't have to do it alone. Holbein takes all of that away. There is the body, the sheet, and the dark wall behind. The ceiling of the tomb is just above him.

And the body is dead in a very physical way. The eyes are still half open. The mouth too. The face, the hand and the feet have started to turn gray and green. The wound in the side is small and dark. You can count the ribs. Nothing is arranged to look noble. He looks like a man who has been dead long enough for it to show, and then left alone.

There is a story that Holbein used a drowned body pulled out of the Rhine as his model. Nobody has ever shown that it is true. But I understand why the story exists. It looks like somebody sat down next to a real corpse and took careful notes.

The finger and the hair

Two small details keep pulling me back. The middle finger of the right hand is lifted a little from the sheet, as if it was about to point at something. And the hair hangs over the front edge of the slab, out of the box and towards us. The painting doesn't quite stay inside itself.

It is also life-size. You don't stand in front of it the way you stand in front of a picture. You stand in front of it the way you stand next to someone.

Dostoevsky on a chair

In August 1867 Fyodor Dostoevsky spent one day in Basel, on the way to Geneva with his young wife Anna. She later wrote that he stood in front of the painting as if stunned. She walked through the other rooms for fifteen or twenty minutes, and when she came back he was still there. In her diary she says he climbed up on a chair to see it closer, and she was worried they would get a fine. In his face she saw the look she knew from the first moments of his epileptic fits. She took his arm and sat him down on a bench. When he had calmed down, he insisted on going back to look again.

Anna did not like it. She admitted it was true to nature but found nothing beautiful in it, and wrote that she would not want to be alone in a room with it. I think that is an honest reaction, and probably a common one.

A year later the painting turns up in The Idiot. Prince Myshkin sees a copy hanging in Rogozhin's gloomy house and says that a man could lose his faith looking at that picture. Rogozhin agrees. Later in the book the dying Ippolit describes the body as proof of nature as a blind, dumb force that swallows everything, even this man.

Why we keep looking

So why have people been so drawn to it? I don't think there is one answer. I have two guesses.

The first is that it doesn't soften anything. Death in most art is made a bit easier to look at. Here it is not, and that kind of honesty is rare enough that you feel it in your body before you have thought about it.

The second is that it stops at exactly the wrong moment. This is the long day in between. Holbein doesn't show what came before or what came after, just the waiting, with nothing in the picture to tell you how it ends. You have to bring that yourself, or not. Dostoevsky saw that it could go either way. I think that is what shook him.

And then, more simply, it is a very good painting. The skin, the folds of the cloth, the small green shadows. Some of the fascination is just that you can't believe paint can do this.

Over the feet, painted to look like it is cut into the stone, there is a date and two letters. MDXXI. H H. The museum's scans show he first wrote 1522 and painted out the last stroke himself. A small correction, on a stone that doesn't exist, five hundred years ago.

People still stand in front of it a little too long.

scroll

I didn't know much about Richard Mosse before I walked into MAST that summer. A good friend of mine, Joachim — a photographer and designer whose taste I trust completely — had been insisting I go. "You have to see this," he kept telling me. So I went, not really knowing what I was walking into.

The photographs were beautiful. That was the first thing. These vast landscapes from the eastern Congo, the forests and rivers glowing in deep magentas and crimsons. I just wanted to look at them.

It took a little while before I started understanding why they made me feel slightly uneasy.

Mosse shot the Congo work on Kodak Aerochrome — an old military surveillance film, infrared, originally designed to detect camouflage from the air. It reads the landscape differently than our eyes do. Chlorophyll comes out red and pink instead of green. So the forests of eastern Congo, ancient and dense and the site of one of the deadliest ongoing conflicts in the world, glow in these extraordinary magentas and crimsons. It looks unreal. And you can't stop looking.

That's kind of the whole problem, and I think Mosse knows it. He's talked about beauty being the sharpest tool for making people feel something. Standing there I felt it working on me in real time — this pull toward images of a place where terrible things have happened, made gorgeous by a film stock originally built for war. It's uncomfortable in a way that's hard to name. You feel a little implicated just for enjoying it.

The video installation Incoming was different. Thermal cameras this time, the kind used to track body heat from military aircraft. Refugees crossing the Mediterranean, rendered as white flames against black. The living and the dead look almost the same. I stood in front of it for a long time and didn't really know what to do with myself.

Afterwards I walked up to the Certosa.

I don't know exactly why. It felt like the right thing to do — like I needed somewhere quiet to put everything I'd just taken in. The Certosa di Bologna is a monumental cemetery inside an old Carthusian monastery, arcaded corridors and marble sculpture and light coming in sideways through high windows. One of those places that feels like it's been waiting for you to come and think something through.

What I kept thinking about was the photographs embedded in the tomb plaques. Oval portraits, sepia and faded, faces behind glass. Ordinary people. You look at them and you know almost nothing — a name, some dates, a face. And I found myself thinking about what Mosse was doing with his images, and what the Certosa was doing with these ones, and whether there's a difference. Both are trying to make the dead visible. Both are doing it with a kind of beauty that asks something from you.

I'm not sure I landed anywhere conclusive. That's okay. Some things you sit with.

I stayed longer than I expected. Walking slowly through the arcades, stopping at faces I didn't know. At some point I stopped trying to think it all through and just let it be a nice afternoon in a beautiful place. The light was very good. It was very quiet.

I sent Joachim a message on the way home. Just: you were right.

Images from congo war
Madona and child
Certosa di Bologna
An image from Certosa di Bologna
More from Certosa di Bologna
scroll

This is a place where I will publish thoughts on things that are important to me, ideas that excite me and random nonsense that amuses me. Stay tuned for more to come. Sten Winroth